Is the Galaxy S10e worth it over the Galaxy S9?

Our pick

Samsung Galaxy S10e

$680 at Amazon

Pros

• Super-fun ultra-wide camera
• Longer runway for software updates
• Improved processor, memory and base storage

Cons

• No huge improvement in battery life
• Screen actually lower resolution

The Galaxy S10e offers a flagship-like experience with top-end specs and capabilities, but does so with a smaller size and lower price than we've come to expect. It's a great option for anyone who wants a smaller or a less expensive phone, and offers outsized value for its price.

Save money

Samsung Galaxy S9

$499 at Walmart

Pros

• Big cost savings for similar core experience
• Screen quality still competitive today

Cons

• Missing ultra-wide camera and portrait mode
• Only likely to receive one more major software update

Despite being a few generation olds, the Galaxy S9 is still an interesting proposition for less money than the Galaxy S10e. It's comparable in many ways, and only misses out on a few small things. It might be a worthwhile purchase if you're really tight on budget.

The Galaxy S10e is a spiritual replacement for last year's Galaxy S9 since the Galaxy S10 has gotten bigger and more expensive. But the Galaxy S9 is still on sale at a solid discount, and that makes it an interesting option for those who want to save money. Here's what you'll get by going with the newer model, or by sticking with an older one.

Galaxy S10e vs. Galaxy S9 Price and availability

In 2020, the Galaxy S10e and Galaxy S9 are not the newest Samsung phones on the block. They're still pretty solid in their own right, but they've since been replaced by newer options. As such, availability can sometimes be a little tricky.

The S10e is still fairly easy to purchase these days, but for the Galaxy S9, buying a new unit for a reasonable price is a challenge. It's not impossible if you know where to look, but big retailers like Best Buy and Amazon are sold out (unless you're OK with a renewed/refurbished model).

If you're in the market for a Galaxy S10e, you can expect to spend $600. Prices flucuate a bit for the S9, but for the most part, it can be had for around $500 or so.

Galaxy S10e vs. Galaxy S9 Where the Galaxy S10e stands out

Samsung is known for taking a cautious approach to improvements with its top-end phones, and that means the Galaxy S10e isn't dramatically improved over the Galaxy S9 in many aspects. But there are certain things you get just by buying a phone made for 2019 rather than 2018.

Spec upgrades aren't super enticing, but you'll appreciate them now and in the future.

The easiest to quantify updates come with the spec sheet, where you upgrade to a Snapdragon 855 processor, 6GB of RAM, and a base of 128GB of storage, which are all zero-downside improvements over the Galaxy S9. None of them mean a ton right now, but as the Galaxy S9 starts to get older, you'll really start to feel the crunch of the limited RAM and storage, if not also the processor. Little improvements in the processor, plus a slightly larger battery and lower-resolution screen, will also offer you just a bit better battery life too.

Another thing you may want to keep in mind when talking about the future of your phone use is the software update roadmap, where the Galaxy S10e obviously has an extra year of runway beyond the Galaxy S9. Both phones are currently running Android 10, but that's the final update the S9 will ever see. Thanks to Samsung's new three-year update policy, the Galaxy S10e is promised to get Android 11 and (hopefully) Android 12.

Category	Galaxy S10e	Galaxy S9
Operating system	Android 10 One UI	Android 10 One UI
Display	5.8-inch AMOLED, 2280x1080 (19:9)	5.8-inch AMOLED, 2960x1440 (18.5:9)
Processor	Snapdragon 855	Snapdragon 845
Storage	128/256GB	64/128/256GB
Expandable	microSD	microSD
RAM	6/8GB	4GB
Rear camera 1	12MP Super Speed Dual Pixel OIS, f/1.5 or f/2.4	12MP Super Speed Dual Pixel OIS, f/1.5 or f/2.4
Rear camera 2	16MP ultra-wide, f/2.2, fixed focus	n/a
Front camera	10MP, f/1.9, auto focus	8MP, f/1.7, auto focus
Audio	Stereo speakers Dolby Atmos 3.5mm headphone	Stereo speakers Dolby Atmos 3.5mm headphone
Battery	3100mAh	3000mAh
Charging	Quick Charge 2.0 (15W) Fast Wireless Charging 2.0 (12W)	Quick Charge 2.0 (15W) Fast Wireless Charging (9W)
Water resistance	IP68	IP68
Security	Side fingerprint sensor	Rear fingerprint sensor
Dimensions	142.2 x 69.9 x 7.9mm 150 g	147.7 x 68.7 x 8.5 mm 163 g

The ultra-wide camera is a treat to shoot with, and selfies took another step up too.

Bigger differences can be found in the cameras. The main rear camera is effectively unchanged from the Galaxy S9, but it's the S10e's supporting set that's interesting. You get an ultra-wide camera with a unique field of view that's just downright fun to shoot with, giving you a new perspective that you just don't get on the Galaxy S9 The front-facing camera is also has a higher resolution and will take your selfies to new levels, even though the Galaxy S9's is quite good as it is.

And whether this last point is a pro, con, or no big deal either way will depend on your personal preference: the Galaxy S10e has a flat display, rather than an "Infinity" curved display like the Galaxy S9. The flat screen reduces accidental touches with your palms, though that's less of an issue on these smaller phones anyway. But if you don't like the curves of the last few generations of Samsung phones, the Galaxy S10e will be a breath of fresh air for you.

Galaxy S10e vs. Galaxy S9 Where the Galaxy S9 is still comparable

It may be over two years old, but the Galaxy S9 is still a modern-feeling phone that's very capable — particularly when compared to the Galaxy S10e.

The Galaxy S9's core experience is effectively the same as the new S10e.

Every part of the external hardware experience of the Galaxy S9 still feels modern. The materials quality, shape, design, fit-and-finish, and everything all down the list is comparable to the Galaxy S10e. Yes, there are differences in look, but you won't feel short-changed by the older model. The display, too, is comparable — it's an older panel, but it's actually higher resolution than the S10e and is still really good even by today's standards. Elsewhere in the hardware the headphone jack, microSD card slot, speakers, and wired charging speed are all the same.

Size-wise, the two phones are basically the same. There are subtle differences in the dimensions, and the curved screen changes the feel, but if you're looking for a "compact" phone you're going to find it with both the Galaxy S9 and S10e.

And realistically, in daily use, you aren't going to notice many differences between these two phones. With the Galaxy S9's update to Android 10, everything is basically the same on both phones. So between the size, performance, software, and core features, you would be able to swap back and forth between the two with little (if any) pain. That bodes well for you if you're thinking about picking the Galaxy S9 for its lower price. The only real downside, software-wise, is that the S9 is at the end of its update lifecycle and is unlikely to get any major update beyond Android 10.

Galaxy S10e vs. Galaxy S9 Which should you buy?

If you're drawn to the Galaxy S10e for both its size and its lower price, there's an interesting argument to be made that you should consider the Galaxy S9. It's roughly the same size as the Galaxy S10e, offers much of the same experience, and is less money because of its age. However, if you're comparing apples-to-apples on 128GB storage models, rather than the Galaxy S9's base 64GB, the value fades a tad — it just depends how much weight you put on internal storage.

The Galaxy S10e is simply a better phone overall than the Galaxy S9, and if you plan to keep your phone for a long time (perhaps upwards of two years), you'd be doing yourself a favor by buying the newer model. You get all of the benefits associated with the newer phone, and don't miss out on anything from the old model. You just have to pay a little extra for it.

Our pick

Samsung Galaxy S10e

$680 at Amazon $600 at Best Buy $600 at Walmart

A better phone that picks up right where the S9 left off

The Galaxy S10e is a proper successor to the Galaxy S9; it just isn't dramatically improved. You get better specs, a new ultra-wide camera, better front-facing camera, and the expectation of stronger longterm performance. It's a better phone, it just costs more as a result..

Save money

Samsung Galaxy S9

$499 at Walmart $550 at Newegg

An interesting alternative if your budget is tight

A lot of what makes the Galaxy S10e appealing can be found for less money in the S9. You get the same core experience, even with the main camera. You miss out on a few hardware upgrades and the new ultra-wide camera, but for for tighter budgets, it's worth a look.

by Andrew Martonik